The Withings ScanWatch Horizon and Steel HR represent a fascinating convergence: the timeless appeal of a traditional analog watch infused with the smarts of a modern fitness tracker. Forget the bulky screens and aggressive styling of many smartwatches; these devices aim for subtlety, prioritizing a classic aesthetic while delivering robust health monitoring capabilities. But does this balancing act succeed? Is it truly the best of both worlds, or does it fall short in crucial areas? Let’s dive in.

Performance-wise, the ScanWatch delivers reliable health tracking. Step counting, heart rate monitoring, and sleep tracking are accurate and consistent with other devices in its class. The built-in ECG and SpO2 sensors offer more advanced health insights, providing users with valuable data to share with their healthcare providers. However, it’s worth noting that these readings are not intended to diagnose or treat medical conditions, and accuracy can vary depending on individual circumstances.

However, the minimalist approach does have its drawbacks. The small PMOLED screen can be difficult to read in bright sunlight, and the limited display real estate means notifications are often truncated. While the watch vibrates for alerts, the lack of detailed information can be frustrating. This necessitates frequent checks on your smartphone, somewhat defeating the purpose of having notifications on your wrist. The lack of onboard GPS means you’ll need to carry your phone for accurate distance tracking during outdoor workouts. Finally, the relatively high price point might be a barrier to entry for some, especially when compared to more feature-rich smartwatches.